Council of Elrond

You misunderstand how the rules and card effects interact. You've shown this elsewhere as well. You can believe whatever you like. You've demonstrated your lack of deductive reasoning and reliance on "knowing" the designers intent without justification. At least I can progress toward bett...

The "main effect" being desired by the player is the general case. The Designer sets the cost based on what they thought the value of the "main effect" would be to the player. It doesn't matter what the player actually desires, but the "main effect" is still the desire...

The only (ICE) cards that overcome the Fallen-wizards restrictions in the White Hand rules come from the White Hand set. You take cyclic logic to new levels of art. Amazing in its own way. Could you present any direct evidence that supports your theory? ----- But there is nothing in this MEWH rule ...

No inheritance in those or something? I just mean I would have thought it would be easier to do once for all cards than these little one-offs. You already have entire classes of cards that can tap/untap/wound/hide/reveal.

No, I do not want it to count as an ally, it is a permanent event that makes a creature an ally.

Why can't all cards in play be affected by /untap, /tap, /invert?

Also needed for the At Home dragon affected by Legendary Hoard.

Good catch. I guess the rulings on Bring Our Curses Home and Foes Shall Fall do not generalize to targeting, then. Seems reasonable, if thematically strained. ----- RthW: Does the creature becoming an ally cause it to cease being a creature? If so, how does one "place this card with the creatur...

Ride Against the Enemy makes a hazard creature attack that can then be targeted by Ready to His Will. How does one place RthW "with the creature," when the creature itself has no physical form? I don't recall previous discussion of this. Should RthW simply be discarded after canceling beca...

Here's my attempt to organize requests for implemented card effects. I'd like some more love for Ready to His Will. Right now it hosts to a character, but that's it. It should host to a creature, and then somehow enable the creature to be hosted to a character, but I'm fine with manually using /host...

You're making stuff up that isn't there. What? The rule merely mentions items being borne. Oh, so you think I didn't make that up. Contradicting yourself? The restrictions are clearly placed on Orc and Troll characters as opposed to non-orc and troll characters. You have a strange knack for using t...

The MEWH restrictions are based on the race of the character, not the race of the bearer: Incomplete. Again, the restrictions [of ignoring bonuses and special abilities] are based on the item being borne by a character of a specific race. It is not a restriction to a specific race regardless of whe...

CDavis7M wrote: ↑Mon Jan 04, 2021 11:59 pm Just because "if A, then B would not apply to C when D" does not necessitate that "B would apply to E when F."

Sure. So why did you use it as a basis for your position?

A necessitates D is in the rules. "Such an attack can occur ONLY if one of the following criterion is met... you MUST choose one of these criterion that the attack is 'keyed to.'" The attack must be keyed. I can see how one might believe A necessitates D when one conveniently drops the C ...

I assume you are aware that there there are multiple rarities of the various different labeled rarities? For METW, it was mostly just the commons that were finicky, but more pronounced for other sets. Was it Pilfer Anything Unwatched that as an "uncommon" was basically as rare as most R2s ...

One last detail I noticed: FW players may use their Fallen-wizard haven cards instead of a hero/minion version; they are not required to use the Haven version.

Here is the full sentence, which a previous post took a piece of "out of context" of the rest of the sentence: An Orc or Troll character may be the bearer of a hero item, but all bonuses and special abilities are ignored (all restrictions to movement and playability still apply). My interp...