There is no time to untap Carambor after Healing of Nimrodel has resolved because it is no longer the "End of the Movement/Hazard phase." I suspected you might go there! I'm still waiting for you to present your evidence on the other thread: Are you ignoring that it is a reference to Anno...

I didn't finish reading; sorry. ... and depend on the site or site path of a moving company ... Spying out the Land does not qualify. Its effect is not repeated. Since its effect cannot be concluded immediately, presumably its effect lasts until end of turn. The other CRF quote might be generalizati...

Sad I missed this. Thanks for representing/correcting, CDavid7M. That Uuldrik was killing me with the non-standard rules.

Also, looking at this again it's clear that Fell-beast could never be played as an automatic-attack at Framsburg regardless of any interpretation differences mentioned above I believe has been ruled that an attack keyed to double Z is also considered keyed to Z (but not to *a* Z). Elven Cloak Can c...

Bilbo and Frodo: Angus McBride
Merry, Pippin, Sam, Robin: Angelo Montanini

Same artist per set of 3 dragon manifestations, except original Smaug and Leucaruth.

Even correcting for dforum -> forum, it looks like the original either no longer exists or is stuck behind permissions.

Oh yes. I'm sorry; I was looking at the Limited version. The Unlimited version does indeed say "may" for the region change. So my appologies; Nenya, Come by Night Upon Them, and The Sun Unveiled are all perfectly fine comparisons to the last effect of The Evenstar. Regarding: Annotation 8,...

Nenya says "Any one". Any could be none. Not an equal comparison to The Evenstar. This still doesn't support your point that all effects must be declarable in order for any of them to be declared. Come by Night Upon Them can be played on a border-hold without an automatic attack in order ...

Regarding "Cannot be duplicated.", I agree that the way this has been interpreted has changed over the years. The CRF is clear: The Evenstar cannot be played if another is having Any effect on gameplay. There is a possibility of the first elf having been removed from play, however, at whic...

Do you believe that More Sense than You could cancel an attack? Konrad also did not think so, and you said you agreed with him.

You can play multiple non-GoM The Evenstar if played on different elves. The effect is different when it has a different target. (For CDavis7M: Scott Frazer 10/24/96) [CRF requires no effect affecting play.] So yes, a non-GoM The Evenstar followed by a GoM The Evenstar with first effect targeting a ...

MELE Defeating an Attack wrote:If the attack is canceled, the attack is not defeated.

Could you clarify what point you intend with regard to the lack of elements for which the property holds?

The Evenstar requires an Elf. Annotation 8: An action that requires a target is considered to have the active condition that the target be in play when the action is declared and when it is resolved. An action may not be declared if its target is not in play. A target is an entity that an action is ...

At least standard axiomatic set theory believes that can be said.

wikipedia wrote: For every property:
For every element of ∅ the property holds (vacuous truth);

Do you have a more recent reference for this? MELE at least says "at the end of the site phase." Balrog Summary and CoE #17 agree. It's based on [NetRep] Rulings Digest #27: Great, thanks. Although I suppose that it could be interpreted as vacuous, since without mentioning the others they...