I like your logic on the wounding from the rules texts. However, how do you account for: The rules on detainment attacks change the result of a successful strike (against the character), not the result a failed a strike (by the attacker). The detainment rules only change the result of defeating all...

Theo wrote: ↑Thu Aug 20, 2020 4:53 pm Furthermore, miguel's wording doesn't address whether or not an agent can be wounded.

It does.

I like your logic on the wounding from the rules texts. However, how do you account for: >Well I guess we won't have to worry about giving away three kill MP's with Golodhros anymore..., but..., can he become wounded? Probably not. No. Agents attacking as detainment cannot be wounded. The rules on ...

Aware of their Ways (and Knowledge of the Enemy) specifically state otherwise Except these cards do not specifically state that the card isn't just discarded (again). We know it is possible to discard cards already in the discard because of the remaining text on Aware of Their Ways. If someone hall...

Do the guidelines for wounding/eliminating agents apply to detainment attacks from agents? Will Gothmog get tired of Golodhros pestering him and simply rip him a new one? --------------------------------------------------- Detainment attacks can't be defeated, so all Gothmog can really do is tell G...

5) Do the sites that have become adjacent to an under-deeps site due to Caverns Unchoked count as surface sites. --------------------------------------------------- The answer is yes, so you cannot play cards like A Few Recruits at those sites anymore. While this might "make sense" becaus...

3) Do the guidelines for wounding/eliminating agents apply to detainment attacks from agents? Will Gothmog get tired of Golodhros pestering him and simply rip him a new one? --------------------------------------------------- Detainment attacks can't be defeated, so all Gothmog can really do is tel...

3) Do the guidelines for wounding/eliminating agents apply to detainment attacks from agents? Will Gothmog get tired of Golodhros pestering him and simply rip him a new one? --------------------------------------------------- Detainment attacks can't be defeated, so all Gothmog can really do is tel...

4) Scenario: I declare hazard play and the hazard limit is checked. My opponent cancels the hazard before it resolves. Question: Is the hazard limit reduced or not? I know the hazard limit is checked on declaration and resolution, but when is the hazard limit actually reduced by the play of a hazar...

5) Do the sites that have become adjacent to an under-deeps site due to Caverns Unchoked count as surface sites. --------------------------------------------------- The answer is yes, so you cannot play cards like A Few Recruits at those sites anymore. While this might "make sense" becaus...

NetRep] CoE Rulings Digest #123 1 a) Can I play play Sacrifice of Form with Crown of Flowers and then later Twilight CoF and play a second SoF? --------------------------------------------------- Yes, if all requirements for such are met, it is legal. This is incorrect. Sacrifice of Form specifical...

From this understanding, all of the other cards and rules are consistent and make sense. You are missing that there are multiple senses of the term "play" used in the rules. The rules are ambiguous. That can mean that there are multiple valid (consistent) interpretations of them; that doe...

Konrad Klar wrote: ↑Sun Apr 08, 2018 11:55 pm I propose the following erratum:

Why? A card cannot fail by itself.

It says right there on the card: "against minion companies" -- which is your opponent's company.

Only the moving player, and the hazard player drawing cards based on his movement, may take advantage of drawing cards, including cards drawn for events like The Nazgul are Abroad and From the Pits of Angband. These two players are also the only ones who may discard a card at the end of the turn. A...

In these rules, two mistakes are made. 1. No such thing as a moving player exists. The active resource player might have several companies, each of which having their moving/hazard phase(s). The expression "moving player" is also used by the Designers, not the Netrep. In fact, this CRF en...