Konrad's proposal seems to include two points. I'm not sure if these were both intentional. * Errata: Defender can no longer choose to not assign any strikes to untapped characters. * Errata: "untapped characters must tap to face any strike" => "untapped character cannot take -3 penal...

I would say that such wording does not capture the purpose of the proposal, which was about the ability to use characters in play with more than 5 mind. Additionally, the wording that is added by the above is paradoxical; there are methods of playing characters beyond bringing them into play under g...

Which issue are you referring to?

Bandobras Took wrote: ↑Wed Aug 28, 2019 2:03 pm FW characters are hero with the exception of Orcs/Trolls, which don't appear to be either hero or minion (barring certain circumstances spelled out in MEWH).

I have considered this before as well. I have a different opinion. Specifically: So discarding A Panoply of Wings makes Information considered playable as written on site I would say no. Discarding makes information playable at the site (following language of Panoply). I know of no resources that re...

(Reference CRF Active Conditions, Annotation 6.)

Thematically this translates to situation where a minion faction is not sensitive to presence of other factions in play if influenced by hero character under control of FW player and sensitive if influenced by Orc or Troll character under control of FW player (in the same company). There is no prov...

Khamul the Easterling wrote: ↑Sun Sep 01, 2019 7:12 am site, if one

There should not be a comma.

But the player would need to if the wording was changed to "a". Emphasis on "would" in my previous post.

I cannot agree. There would be no objective way to differentiate discrepancies (in which MELE rules take precedence) vs. simply differences.

Is an undead attack keyed to Shadow-lands only detainment if played by a Ringwraith player? No Can a Wizard player play METW Lure of Nature on Orcs? No. (Ignoring CoL already solving Lure of Nature: "The mechanics of any given card will be determined from the most recent English printing (as w...

I'm not sure what you're saying they are forgetting. You are implying that there is something for them to remember. There isn't.

Wrong 'droids.

The fact that it would require that the target is in your discard pile is sufficient to except it from the general rule, in my opinion.

Unless they have a special ability allowing them to, agents may not move to a site, one of its versions is currently in play as a hero Haven or Wizardhaven. If there is no version of the site currently in play, agents may not move to a site that is a hero Haven or Wizard haven in any player's site ...

The verdict is contentious.

Hopefully your play group can read the ideas discussed and come to a mutually acceptable, consistent decision for yourselves.

If this came up at e.g. Worlds... it would probably go to the loudest group present, regardless of thoughtful discussion. Speculating.

Ah yes. I forgot we were dealing with a Permanent Event here, so an ongoing passive condition it is! All good.