Contradicting/unclear CRF rules concerning hoards
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 4:55 pm
http://www.meccg.net/dforum/viewtopic.php?t=2705
Proposed solution:
Changing
"If a manifestation of a unique Dragon is defeated, then the automatic-attack at the associated site is removed, and that site therefore loses its hoard status."
to
"If a manifestation of a unique Dragon is defeated, then the automatic-attack at the associated site is removed".
Removed phrase "and that site therefore loses its hoard status." is not needed and imprecise, "Each site which had a Dragon automatic-attack at the beginning of the turn contains a hoard." is sufficient and accurate regulation of effects caused by removing site's Dragon AA (which may occur not only as result of eliminating a Dragon Manifestation).
However:CRF,Errata (Rules) wrote:Dragon Rules, Hoards: Change "Each site with a Dragon automatic-attack (i.e., each Dragon's Lair) contains a hoard" to "Each site which had a Dragon automatic-attack at the beginning of the turn contains a hoard."
destroys previous erratum.CRF, Rulings by Term, Dragons wrote:If a manifestation of a unique Dragon is defeated, then the automatic-attack at the associated site is removed, and that site therefore loses its hoard status.
Proposed solution:
Changing
"If a manifestation of a unique Dragon is defeated, then the automatic-attack at the associated site is removed, and that site therefore loses its hoard status."
to
"If a manifestation of a unique Dragon is defeated, then the automatic-attack at the associated site is removed".
Removed phrase "and that site therefore loses its hoard status." is not needed and imprecise, "Each site which had a Dragon automatic-attack at the beginning of the turn contains a hoard." is sufficient and accurate regulation of effects caused by removing site's Dragon AA (which may occur not only as result of eliminating a Dragon Manifestation).