[V] Memories recalled

[marcos]

I'm back with a suggestion after a long time with a virtual one for real life play for those who can't afford a longbottom leaf:

[V] Memories recalled
Short event
Playable only if your playdeck has at least 5 cards. A character with 6 mind or more (or a wizard) at a site can tap to bring up to 2 cards from sideboard to playdeck and shuffle. Can't be included in a deck that contains any copy of longbottom leaf. Remove this card from the game.

I wanted to help those who can't afford a longbottom leaf and use to play virtual games in real life...

Opinions?

[Bandobras Took]

Rather than "can't be included with Longbottom Leaf," say "may not be played if you have removed Longbottom Leaf from the game." It accomplishes the same thing since a player likely won't include both in their deck, but it's far easier to check the legality.

[marcos]

in that case you could play memories recalled V first and then longbottom leaf for 8 sb cards... I think that is too much, i don't want both to coexist in the same deck because this one if for those who don't have access to Balrog cards...

What about:

"may not be played if you have removed Longbottom Leaf from the game and longbottom leaf may not be played if you have removed memories recalled from the game"

[Leon]

I do not think it is sensible to duplicate or nearly duplicate existing cards, even if they are very rare. In casual games and on internet people can also use proxies, so I do not see the need for this card.

[marcos]

at tournaments, proxies are not allowed... and there are many people who really loves to play and can't afford very expensive cards, i think we should give such players a chance to compete with those who does have the chance to get some of the most rare cards in the game... Of course with this i don't mean to duplicate the entire balrog set, i just think the sb access that Lbottom Leaf gives is key for most of the hero decks

[Leon]

There is already the slightly weaker but somewhat more versatile Smoke Rings, which I often even prefer above Longbottom Leaf.

And if getting the expensive cards proves to be a hopeless problem for newer players, allowing proxies at tournaments would be an option as well.

[marcos]

There is already the slightly weaker but somewhat more versatile Smoke Rings, which I often even prefer above Longbottom Leaf.

of course but both smoke rings and lbottom leaf can coexist in a deck for optimal sb access...

And if getting the expensive cards proves to be a hopeless problem for newer players, allowing proxies at tournaments would be an option as well.

Of course, but that goes to the tournament organizer's will...