MPs for Trophies

Any rule erratum or clarification submission for the upcoming 2019 ARV should be posted here.
Post Reply
User avatar
Theo
Posts: 542
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2018 5:49 pm
Location: Denver, CO

MPs for Trophies

Post by Theo » Sat Apr 13, 2019 4:33 am

CRF wrote:Creatures whose marshalling points are listed with an * give marshalling points while used as trophies.
This seems misleading for Fallen Wizard players post full orc/troll citizenship status. I propose the following clarifying amendment:

"When used as trophies, creatures that could have been placed in your marshalling point pile give marshalling points as though they had been placed in your marshalling point pile."
It is not our part here to take thought only for a season, or for a few lives of Men, or for a passing age of the world.
One family of busy dwarves with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make---or one online community. Cautious skill!

User avatar
the Jabberwock
Council Chairman
Posts: 1132
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by the Jabberwock » Tue Jun 25, 2019 4:32 am

I'm unclear on what the problem is. Is the issue that a trophy taken for a Fallen-wizard player's orc/troll should only be worth 1 MP instead of full kill points as listed on the card? If so, I don't think the CRF quoted over-rides the MP rules for Fallen-wizards as outlined in the White Hand rulebook.

But it seems maybe the issue is something else. Please clarify.

An aside, creatures that will not give a player kill points, may still be placed in your marshalling point pile (worth 0 points) when the creature is defeated, correct?

User avatar
Theo
Posts: 542
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2018 5:49 pm
Location: Denver, CO

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by Theo » Tue Jun 25, 2019 4:48 am

There are two issues with the rules as written:
They do not reward MP (to Fallen Wizard) for non-* trophy.
They always reward MP (to Fallen Wizard) for * trophy.

I believe the intent of the CRF entry is to establish that trophies should not take away from your normal marshalling point accumulations (unless the character loses the trophy or is themselves is lost and taking the trophy with them).
Last edited by Theo on Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:07 am, edited 1 time in total.
It is not our part here to take thought only for a season, or for a few lives of Men, or for a passing age of the world.
One family of busy dwarves with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make---or one online community. Cautious skill!

User avatar
the Jabberwock
Council Chairman
Posts: 1132
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by the Jabberwock » Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:02 am

Theo wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 4:48 am
I believe the intent of the CRF entry is to establish that trophies should not take away from your normal marshalling point accumulations (unless the character loses the trophy or is themselves is lost and taking the trophy with them).
I agree. Although I seem to recall there is also a provision that allows the player to still claim the marshalling points of a trophy if the bearing character is removed from play or discarded (I could be wrong).

Theo wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 4:48 am
There are two issues with the rules as written:
They do not reward MP (to Fallen Wizard) for non-* trophy.
They always reward MP (to Fallen Wizard) for * trophy.
Will you please quote the rules you are referencing? Thanks

User avatar
Theo
Posts: 542
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2018 5:49 pm
Location: Denver, CO

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by Theo » Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:08 am

the Jabberwock wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 4:32 am
An aside, creatures that will not give a player kill points, may still be placed in your marshalling point pile (worth 0 points) when the creature is defeated, correct?
MELE wrote:If you defeat a creature that does not have an * next to its marshalling points, place the card in your out-of-play pile. You do not receive marshalling points for eliminating it.
Subtle difference.
It is not our part here to take thought only for a season, or for a few lives of Men, or for a passing age of the world.
One family of busy dwarves with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make---or one online community. Cautious skill!

User avatar
Theo
Posts: 542
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2018 5:49 pm
Location: Denver, CO

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by Theo » Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:16 am

the Jabberwock wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:02 am
Although I seem to recall there is also a provision that allows the player to still claim the marshalling points of a trophy if the bearing character is removed from play or discarded (I could be wrong).
Quite right; I was confusing the CRF entry saying that they could be stolen by Thieves. True, but if so they are then placed in the MP pile. Corrected above.
the Jabberwock wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:02 am
Theo wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 4:48 am
There are two issues with the rules as written:
They do not reward MP (to Fallen Wizard) for non-* trophy.
They always reward MP (to Fallen Wizard) for * trophy.
Will you please quote the rules you are referencing? Thanks
One could argue that the original post CRF reference is the only provision for trophies, as trophies, being worth Marshalling Points. But I could also see this going the other way. Regardless, the CRF could be interpreted to overrule Fallen Wizards not normally receiving * points.
It is not our part here to take thought only for a season, or for a few lives of Men, or for a passing age of the world.
One family of busy dwarves with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make---or one online community. Cautious skill!

User avatar
the Jabberwock
Council Chairman
Posts: 1132
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by the Jabberwock » Thu Jun 27, 2019 5:04 am

Theo wrote:
Tue Jun 25, 2019 5:16 am
One could argue that the original post CRF reference is the only provision for trophies, as trophies, being worth Marshalling Points. But I could also see this going the other way.
I see. I would argue that "Creatures whose marshalling points are listed with an * give marshalling points while used as trophies" does not necessarily mean "Creatures whose marshalling points are not listed with an * do not give marshalling points while used as trophies."

However, after passage of CoE Erratum #31 https://councilofelrond.org/forum/viewt ... 103&t=3532, I would argue that a Fallen-wizard player who controls a company of Orc/Trolls does receive MPs for * hazard creatures defeated by that company (trophy or not) and they do not receive MPs for non-* hazard creatures defeated by that company.
The White Hand Rulebook:
When you play a Fallen-wizard, assume that your Fallen-wizard is a METW “Wizard”. All of the normal
METW rules apply except for the specific exceptions outlined in these rules.
CoE Erratum #31 is a specific exception to this rule regarding treating your Fallen-wizard as a METW Wizard (for the purposes of Orcs & Trolls and how they are handled... to include kill points)

So my opinion is that Erratum 31, not the CRF, overrules FW not normally receiving * points. And the CRF continues to clarify points for trophies.

User avatar
Theo
Posts: 542
Joined: Mon Jan 08, 2018 5:49 pm
Location: Denver, CO

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by Theo » Sat Jun 29, 2019 12:23 am

I think you are confusing Orc and Troll characters/companies rules and player scoring rules. CoE Erratum #31 does not change that a player receives MP or not based on his alignment (and, in my opinion, this is the way it should be). CoE Erratum #31 no more overrules that Fallen Wizards get full points for items borne by Orcs/Troll, or other such unrelated rules. The CRF rule speaks directly to scoring, and could be construed as breaking normal alignment rules. You might like that, but I don't, and I'd like to vote to fix this CRF rule that was created long before the CoE Erratum #31 context.
It is not our part here to take thought only for a season, or for a few lives of Men, or for a passing age of the world.
One family of busy dwarves with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make---or one online community. Cautious skill!

User avatar
the Jabberwock
Council Chairman
Posts: 1132
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am

Re: MPs for Trophies

Post by the Jabberwock » Fri Jul 12, 2019 6:34 pm

Theo wrote:
Sat Jun 29, 2019 12:23 am
I think you are confusing Orc and Troll characters/companies rules and player scoring rules.
You are right, my apologies. After going back and carefully re-reading CoE Erratum # 31, the MELE Rulebook, and the MEWH Rulebook, I rescind my previous opinion.

I agree that clarifying this point is worthwhile.

Wording of the rules aside for a moment and speaking thematically:
While it seems logical to me that an overt Orc and Troll company under the allegiance of a Fallen-wizard would net Kill Points for their Fallen-wizard when defeating asterisk creatures (don't you think Saruman was empowered and satisfied when his Uruk-hai slaughtered Elves and Men?), I can also understand the counter-argument that a Fallen-wizard, generally speaking, is going to be rewarded and get empowerment out of somewhat different tactics and methods than a Ringwraith/Sauron/Balrog might. So perhaps FWs, in general, would not be outwardly in favor (and empowered by) some of the same methods used by minion players.

Post Reply

Return to “2019 Annual Rules Vote - Submissions”