I have read in a lot of places (here too) that ALiYE is not so useful, that nobody uses it, or definitively that it "sucks". I am still not the big connoisseur of many cards and I believe I haven't used it, but, just thinking: I would say the most people that get the card played against them take the last sentence: "choose for you to make a roll. If the result is greater than the character’s mind plus 6, the character is discarded (along with all cards he controls)". And with a character with mind for example of 6, the card has no meaning. On the other hand, a character with mind 2 could be maybe discarded. But, to discard a weak character is not the great deal. But, if the character has mind 4, this character could be more powerful and it is good to discard him, although one should roll 11 or 12 to discard him. It as that a little difficult. Are these the reasons that the cards is considered not useful or is it something else?
A LIE IN YOUR EYES ‐ Short‐event (R)
Playable on an untapped non‐Ringwraith, non‐Wizard character. Your opponent may either; tap the character, tap an ally the
character controls, or choose for you to make a roll. If the result is greater than the character’s mind plus 6, the character is
discarded (along with all cards he controls).