Yegor wrote: ↑Sun Jan 06, 2019 6:24 pm
The question was how you imagined shuffling your opponent's card into your play deck.
I can understand looking at opponent's cards.
I can understand discarding his hazards.
I can even understand discarding his hard-earned resources (though I am absolutely against it).
But shuffling his card into your play deck is outright silly.
If you can imagine at all a shuffling a card into play deck, then there is a chance that you can imagine a shuffling a "foo" card into play deck (where "foo" may be "site", "opponent's", or any other type of card you do not want to be shuffled into play deck).
Yegor wrote: ↑Sun Jan 06, 2019 6:24 pm
Live and learn. Please, point me to the section in the rules, where it is allowed to add sites to your hand. I must be a very unattentive reader
Yegor wrote: ↑Sun Jan 06, 2019 6:24 pm
I will tell him to prove that this is legal in the first place. In this case I'm against presumption of innocence. If he can't, he will either not be able to perform it, or will have to finish the game on his own.
So live and learn, as you says.
Other approach is "what is not forbidden is allowed".
Can you play a character card in organization phase? If so, do you need an additional permission for Wacho, or Vygavril?
I cannot imagine a shuffling a faction into play deck, as I cannot imagine a placing a site in discard pile.
I can imagine a shuffling, or a placing in discard pile a card that represent the faction, or site (respectively) in question.
Ready to His Will, and Memories of Old Torture allow to use an opponent's (or your own, if hypothetical effect allows for facing them) creatures as your allies. There are no rules that allow for that. Text of the card is sufficient.
If there is a rule that restrict in some way an object on which some action is performed, the restriction must be obeyed, or explicitly overridden.
There is no rule that forbids a placing an opponent's card in play deck or in hand. If it is a problem. then propose a rule that forbids it.