I'm sure there are many more scenarios which would fall under this umbrella topic, but here are two specific ones:
First Scenario
I play Echoes of the Song on my opponent and he chooses to discard Thrall of the Voice which is played with Legolas.
Legolas now reverts back to his original 6 mind attribute. The White Hand rules book states:
"... you may only use a character if his mind attribute is 5 or less."
So what does "use" mean? What now happens to Legolas? Can he move? Can he face strikes? Does he still count for Marshaling Points?
Second Scenario
I play Echoes of the Song on my opponent and he chooses to discard a Hidden Haven which was played on a site which also has Guarded Haven played on the same site. So the associated site ceases to be a haven, but it is still a protected site and still provides 1 MP from the Guarded Haven card, correct?
Discarding Stage Resources & Their Ripple Effects
- Bandobras Took
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 3109
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 2:30 pm
Hidden Haven can't satisfy Echoes.Discard this card when the site is discarded or returned to its location deck. It cannot be discarded otherwise.
As for the first question, it's anybody's guess what "use" means in that rule. My own personal philosophy is here.
The game is flawed, but this does not mean it cannot be loved.
- the JabberwocK
- Ex Council Chairman
- Posts: 1156
- Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am
Apologies as I forgot to reply to your post.
To add to the discussion, does anyone have opinions on what USE means with this card: Cast From the Order
- Must retrieve minion sites from one's location deck instead of hero sites?
OR
- May not travel to a hero site already in play?
OR
- May not tap a hero site to play a resource?
OR
- May not play any resources or cards whatsoever at a hero site?
If I have already revealed and declared movement to a hero Border-hold and during the company's M/H phase Cast From the Order is successfully played, what happens?
Do we treat this scenario like a successful River affect? The company arrives at the hero site but can do nothing? Or does use have a more limited meaning?
If a company is already present at a hero Border-hold when Cast From the Order is played, what are their options?
Thoughts welcome.
Both players totally missed that during the game! Good catch!Bandobras Took wrote: ↑Fri Oct 12, 2018 10:43 pmHidden Haven can't satisfy Echoes.Discard this card when the site is discarded or returned to its location deck. It cannot be discarded otherwise.
Thanks for sharing your philosophy. So you believe the character becomes a "Lump" as you say. Do you believe they still count for character Marshaling Points?Bandobras Took wrote: ↑Fri Oct 12, 2018 10:43 pm As for the first question, it's anybody's guess what "use" means in that rule. My own personal philosophy is here.
To add to the discussion, does anyone have opinions on what USE means with this card: Cast From the Order
Does use here mean:CAST FROM THE ORDER ‐ Permanent‐event (R)
Playable on a Fallen‐wizard. Make a roll and add the Fallen‐wizardʹs stage points. If the result is less than 16, discard this card. Otherwise, place this card with the Fallen‐wizard. The Fallen‐wizardʹs player must use minion sites for Border‐holds [ ], Free‐holds[ ], and hero Havens. Also, the Fallen‐wizardʹs company is overt.
- Must retrieve minion sites from one's location deck instead of hero sites?
OR
- May not travel to a hero site already in play?
OR
- May not tap a hero site to play a resource?
OR
- May not play any resources or cards whatsoever at a hero site?
If I have already revealed and declared movement to a hero Border-hold and during the company's M/H phase Cast From the Order is successfully played, what happens?
Do we treat this scenario like a successful River affect? The company arrives at the hero site but can do nothing? Or does use have a more limited meaning?
If a company is already present at a hero Border-hold when Cast From the Order is played, what are their options?
Thoughts welcome.
My guess is that from now on corresponding sites must be played. But that should not affect sites already in play.the Jabberwock wrote: ↑Wed Nov 14, 2018 3:29 am - Must retrieve minion sites from one's location deck instead of hero sites?
- Konrad Klar
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 4368
- Joined: Sun Feb 04, 2007 9:35 am
- Location: Wałbrzych, Poland
Cast From the Order says about necessity of using minion sites for given site types.
This is not a restriction, this is a warrant.
I see a two ways of fulfilling the warrant.
- Using a minion site card when a site under control of affected player happen to be of given type.
- Using a minion site card if a site card under control of affected player would be otherwise of given type.
In first case, after playing Rebuild the Town on hero site card, the hero site card would be replaced with minion site card and Rebuild the Town would illegally target a minion site card.
Second way means replacing all site cards of given types under control of affected player with cards of minion version. The case seems to be less problematic, especially the there is no minion version of sites of type "hero haven". There is a minion version of site cards of type "hero haven".
This is not a restriction, this is a warrant.
I see a two ways of fulfilling the warrant.
- Using a minion site card when a site under control of affected player happen to be of given type.
- Using a minion site card if a site card under control of affected player would be otherwise of given type.
In first case, after playing Rebuild the Town on hero site card, the hero site card would be replaced with minion site card and Rebuild the Town would illegally target a minion site card.
Second way means replacing all site cards of given types under control of affected player with cards of minion version. The case seems to be less problematic, especially the there is no minion version of sites of type "hero haven". There is a minion version of site cards of type "hero haven".
The replacing happens immediately, once Cast From the Order is in play.the Jabberwock wrote: ↑Wed Nov 14, 2018 3:29 am If I have already revealed and declared movement to a hero Border-hold and during the company's M/H phase Cast From the Order is successfully played, what happens?
Do we treat this scenario like a successful River affect? The company arrives at the hero site but can do nothing? Or does use have a more limited meaning?
If a company is already present at a hero Border-hold when Cast From the Order is played, what are their options?
We will not speak of such things even in the morning of the Shire.
- Bandobras Took
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 3109
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 2:30 pm
I believe so. Likewise, they're still in play even though they can't be used.the Jabberwock wrote: ↑Wed Nov 14, 2018 3:29 amThanks for sharing your philosophy. So you believe the character becomes a "Lump" as you say. Do you believe they still count for character Marshaling Points?
The game is flawed, but this does not mean it cannot be loved.
To make sure I'm following, is Rebuild the Town not lost for the second case because a site that has merely been altered to be a Border-hold is not affected by Cast From the Order under the second way? I see how that would avoid the paradox of being at a Ruins and Lairs, playing Rebuild the Town, which would then require replacement to a minion version, which would then not be affected by Rebuild the Town, which would then mean it is still a Ruins and Lairs, which means it does not need to be replaced, which means it can still be affected by Rebuild the Town, ad infinitum.Konrad Klar wrote: ↑Wed Nov 14, 2018 8:03 am Cast From the Order says about necessity of using minion sites for given site types.
This is not a restriction, this is a warrant.
I see a two ways of fulfilling the warrant.
- Using a minion site card when a site under control of affected player happen to be of given type.
- Using a minion site card if a site card under control of affected player would be otherwise of given type.
In first case, after playing Rebuild the Town on hero site card, the hero site card would be replaced with minion site card and Rebuild the Town would illegally target a minion site card.
Second way means replacing all site cards of given types under control of affected player with cards of minion version. The case seems to be less problematic, especially the there is no minion version of sites of type "hero haven". There is a minion version of site cards of type "hero haven".
What happens with something like Refuge, which has no minion version? How is the warrant fulfilled then?
My main takeaway is that "must use minion sites" here is interpreted as "must replace non-minion sites with a same-named minion site". The replacement mechanism not being explicitly stated seems a little weird to me, but at least it would be more streamlined in how to handle various "use" situations for sites already in play vs. selecting future sites than delving into how to NOT "use" non-minion sites.
However, it returns to the old question: if the effected Fallen Wizard is doing the replacement, what happens if they don't have the replacement needed? Auto-forfeit?
One [online community] with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make...
All players are welcome at Meduseld! https://theo-donly.github.io/MECCG/
All players are welcome at Meduseld! https://theo-donly.github.io/MECCG/
- the JabberwocK
- Ex Council Chairman
- Posts: 1156
- Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am
Okay, after doing some more digging and discussing with another player, the following came to light:
CoE NetRep Rulings Digest #19
So this NetRep decided that "must use minion sites" means "replace all existing hero sites in play with minion sites." Personally, I think this is stretching the interpretation of the word USE a bit, but okay, I respect the ruling.
However, what happens when Cast from the Order leaves play? Do the minion sites automatically switch back to hero versions? If not, why not? If a mandate to use a certain card means replacing the site, then shouldn't the mandate being removed mean reverting the site?
CoE NetRep Rulings Digest #19
CoE NetRep Rulings Digest #54Or if you have a company moving to a Refuge, and you are Cast From the Order?
*** If you are Cast from the Order from a previous turn, you may not play Refuge. If you have Cast from the Order played on you while you're moving to Refuge, as per the CRF under "sites", your opponent must provide the minion version of the site if you don't have it available. Neither of you can do that so you get to the normal Refuge.
Heart Grown Cold functions the same as Cast From the Order, so this ruling would apply to handling Cast from the Order as well.How can Poison of His Voice do anything to Heart Grown Cold? HGC is
permanent, while PoHV only last till the end of the turn. And since
HGC is played during the M/H-phase, sites have already been played and
are not affected by HGC, right? I assume HGC only affect the
_playing_ of a site, and does not change sites already in play? Or
does it?
*** Heart Grown Cold will cause all affected sites in play to be
swapped out with a site of the appropriate alignment. If the resource
player doesn't own an appropriate version of that site, the hazard
player must provide it. Subsequent sites played must adhere to Heart
Grown Cold's requirements unless, of course, it is removed from play.
So this NetRep decided that "must use minion sites" means "replace all existing hero sites in play with minion sites." Personally, I think this is stretching the interpretation of the word USE a bit, but okay, I respect the ruling.
However, what happens when Cast from the Order leaves play? Do the minion sites automatically switch back to hero versions? If not, why not? If a mandate to use a certain card means replacing the site, then shouldn't the mandate being removed mean reverting the site?
- Bandobras Took
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 3109
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 2:30 pm
Unless a card specifically alters this rule, it remains in force.MEWH Rules wrote:A fallen-wizard's non-overt companies must use hero sites for sites that are not Ruins & Lairs.
As for the "use" of a site card, the rule seems to be saying that this includes all of a company's interactions with a site card.
The game is flawed, but this does not mean it cannot be loved.
- the JabberwocK
- Ex Council Chairman
- Posts: 1156
- Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 4:46 am
Okay, so let's say Cast From the Order comes into play while a tapped Wellinghall is in play. The minion version of Wellinghall now replaces the hero version. Does the hero Wellinghall now go to the discard pile since it was tapped? Once Cast From the Order leaves play, does the hero version of Wellinghall now come back into play from the discard pile? If not, what happens?Bandobras Took wrote: ↑Thu Nov 15, 2018 4:16 amUnless a card specifically alters this rule, it remains in force.MEWH Rules wrote:A fallen-wizard's non-overt companies must use hero sites for sites that are not Ruins & Lairs.
As for the "use" of a site card, the rule seems to be saying that this includes all of a company's interactions with a site card.
- Bandobras Took
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 3109
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 2:30 pm
An exchange is just that -- you put the one site wherever the other one was and in the same position. A tapped hero Wellinghall would return to wherever minion Wellinghall was.The play of certain cards can change the type of sites that your companies may use (e.g. Plotting Ruin, Heart Grown Cold, etc.). When this happens, immediately exchange any affected site cards already in play with the corresponding site cards of the proper type.
The game is flawed, but this does not mean it cannot be loved.
- Konrad Klar
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 4368
- Joined: Sun Feb 04, 2007 9:35 am
- Location: Wałbrzych, Poland
If a site card is not type of , , or hero haven, then it is not lost.
It may happen that e.g. a Nature's Revenge is on hero site card Bree and Rebuild the Town is played on top.
If the site card Bree is replaced with minion version, then Rebuild the Town targets the site card illegally.
It cannot be played. And if already in play, because it cannot be replaced and an opponent cannot provide an appropriate copy, Cast From the Order cannot be played.
I do not know. Need of such replacement may happen also in result of discarding a card like Cast From the Order. ICE's smart concept of putting responsibility for providing an appropriate site card on a player who plays a card causing replacement does not work here.
We will not speak of such things even in the morning of the Shire.
I would find it conceptually weird that a Fallen Wizard couldn't be Cast from the Order if they have any character in a Refuge under their influence...
To avoid undefined states, I'd be more comfortable with wording "exchange if possible". If the Fallen Wizard can't exchange, then they must give their opponent a chance. If neither player can exchange, then the original site remains (and is useable).
To avoid undefined states, I'd be more comfortable with wording "exchange if possible". If the Fallen Wizard can't exchange, then they must give their opponent a chance. If neither player can exchange, then the original site remains (and is useable).
One [online community] with hammer and chisel might mar more than they make...
All players are welcome at Meduseld! https://theo-donly.github.io/MECCG/
All players are welcome at Meduseld! https://theo-donly.github.io/MECCG/
- Bandobras Took
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 3109
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 2:30 pm
I'm not certain there's a rule that prohibits the play of such a card if there is not an available minion site.
The game is flawed, but this does not mean it cannot be loved.
- Konrad Klar
- Rules Wizard
- Posts: 4368
- Joined: Sun Feb 04, 2007 9:35 am
- Location: Wałbrzych, Poland
Bandobras Took wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 8:42 pm I'm not certain there's a rule that prohibits the play of such a card if there is not an available minion site.
Then the "you must" means "you must if you can".White Hand, Overview, Sites wrote:If you play a hazard forcing a Fallen-wizard to change site alignments, and he does
not have the other version of the site he is moving to, you must provide it for him.
After that it is his responsibility to provide sites.
We will not speak of such things even in the morning of the Shire.